www.duncangrehan.com


Archive of Reports
May 2001 - Recent ASAI News

Date:

1.

 
Topic:

Misleading Advertising

Who:

Advertising Standards Authority of Ireland

When:

April 2001

Where:

Ireland

What happened:

A press advertisement recruiting warehouse personnel for Abbott Ireland was   the subject of an objection. The complainant was informed after he had applied for a position with the company that the minimum entry requirements for any position in the company was leaving certificate or an equivalent educational qualification. No mention of any minimum entry requirements was made in the advertisements.

The Advertising Standards Authority noted that the advertisement had been withdrawn from further publication. Under the Advertising Standards Code advertisements should not mislead by inaccuracy, ambiguity, omission or otherwise. Specifically in relation to employment opportunities the terms and conditions should not be misrepresented. The omission of any reference to a requirement that the candidate have a Leaving Certificate was in contravention of the Code and the complaint was upheld.

Comment:

Job advertisements should not be misleading as to minimum eligibility requirements.

 

2.

 

Topic:

Taste and Decency in Advertising

Who:

Advertising Standards Authority of Ireland

When:

April 2001

Where:

Ireland

What happened:

A series of billboard advertisements for Coca-Cola was the subject of a number of consumer complaints and a complaint from the Islamic Cultural Centre of Ireland. The posters showed a topless young woman with one breast covered and holding a bottle of Diet Coke. Consumers complained that the posters were unsuitable for viewing by the general public and more particularly children, that they exploited women and were sexually suggestive. The Islamic Cultural Centre objected to a poster being placed beside their premises as they felt it was particularly offensive to the Muslim community.

The advertisers responded that they had not intended to cause offence to any members of the public. They said that Diet Coke was targeted at 20 – 39 year olds  and the ad was based on the image of Diet Coke as young, fashionable, sexy product. They stated that they had also received a positive reaction to the campaign.

The ASAI stated that advertisers are required to take account of public sensitivities and to avoid the exploitation of sexuality in advertisements. They should not use offensive or provocative images as a means of attracting attention. The Authority decided that these advertisements had caused widespread offence and had not adhered to the Code so the complaints were upheld.

Comment:

Advertisers should ensure that the images portrayed in advertisements will not cause widespread offence.

 

3.

 
Topic: Taste and Decency in Advertising
Who: Advertising Standards Authority of Ireland
When: April 2001
Where: Ireland
What happened: A poster campaign by Levi Jeans was the subject of objections. The posters featured a topless female model (with her breasts covered) in a variety of poses both on her own and with a topless male model. The complainants said that the posters were offensive, sexually suggestive and claimed they were exploiting young people. There were also criticisms of the siting of the posters at bus shelters and near schools.The advertisers responded that they had run this campaign throughout Europe without any complaints. They stated that the man and the woman in the posters were mature adults and well within the age of consent.  The images were aimed at emotional tenderness rather than overt sexuality.The ASAI stated that advertisers should take into account public sensitivity and avoid the exploitation of sexuality and the use of coarseness and undesirable innuendo.  It stated that the posters and in particular their location at bus shelters and near schools had given rise to widespread offence and so upheld the complaints.
Comment: The location of advertisements should be taken into account by advertisers.

 

4.

 
Topic: Use of religion and unauthorised use of persons images in advertising.
Who: Advertising Standards Authority of Ireland
When: April 2001
Where: Ireland
What happened: An advertisement in the press for Ryanair was objected to. It showed a photograph of Pope John Paul II and Cardinal Desmond Connell with a speech bubble drawn from the Pope’s mouth saying “Is it true that RYANAIR.com guarantees the lowest fares?” and a speech bubble from the Cardinals mouth responding “Is the Pope a Catholic?”.  Complainants felt it was insulting to their religious beliefs and to the people shown.  The advertisers rejected any allegations that they had behaved with anything less than a sense of responsibility to society. They did not state if they had obtained written permission from the persons portrayed. The complaint was upheld. The Advertising Standards Code states that particular care should be taken to avoid causing offence on grounds of religion. It is also a requirement under the Code that advertisers should have written permission in advance from anyone mentioned or referred to in an advertisement. The Complaints Committee of the ASAI found this ad to be in breach of both these provisions. 
Comment: Particular care should be taken not to cause offence on grounds of religion.
 
Email: mail@duncangrehan.com Phone:+353-1-6779078  Fax:+353-1-6779076 Gainsboro House, 24 Suffolk Street, Dublin 2, Ireland. © 2004. All data is provided for information only, for professional advice please contact us.